Secret Stash - Outstanding Pizzas (and more) in Crested Butte, CO
- PePe T.
- 3 days ago
- 3 min read
Seated in the heart of downtown Crested Butte, Secret Stash isn’t just a pizza restaurant—it’s an experience that captures the creative, free-spirited essence of this mountain town. With its eclectic atmosphere, lively energy, and unforgettable pizzas, Secret Stash has become a local legend and a must-visit stop for anyone exploring Crested Butte. Whether you’re a ski enthusiast coming off the slopes or a foodie seeking a memorable meal, this place delivers on every level.
The interior of Secret Stash immediately sets the tone for what’s to come. Colorful walls, playful art, and an array of quirky décor create an inviting space that feels both laid-back and full of character. There’s always a happy buzz in the air—families laughing, friends clinking glasses, and the aroma of wood-fired pizza drifting through the room. The atmosphere embodies what Crested Butte is all about: a blend of mountain-town charm and artistic individuality.
Secret Stash’s menu is a masterpiece of imagination and quality. Rather than sticking to traditional toppings, the restaurant has become famous for its bold and inventive combinations. Every pizza is a culinary adventure, made with fresh, premium ingredients and a perfect crust that strikes the ideal balance between chewy and crispy. It’s easy to see why locals fiercely defend this as their go-to spot for pizza perfection. Among the standout creations, the “Notorious FIG” is a fan favorite. It features a combination of mozzarella, bleu cheese, prosciutto, and fresh figs, all drizzled with a sweet balsamic reduction that ties the flavors together beautifully. The contrast between salty, savory, and sweet makes it one of the most memorable pizzas you’ll ever taste. It’s a bold choice that perfectly showcases the kitchen’s fearless creativity.
Another classic is the “Mac Daddy,” which redefines indulgence. Imagine a pizza layered with 100% beef, special sauce, mozzarella, cheddar, onions, lettuce, and pickles—essentially a Big Mac reinvented on a pizza crust. It’s outrageous, over-the-top, and utterly delicious. Few restaurants can pull off something so playful while still delivering a perfectly balanced, crave-worthy dish. Of course, not everything on the menu is wild experimentation. For those who crave simplicity done right, the “Cheesus Crust” or the “Stash House Pie” offer traditional flavors elevated by high-quality ingredients and that perfect crust. You can also build your own pizza, choosing from an impressive list of sauces, cheeses, meats, and vegetables. The staff is always happy to help customize your order, ensuring every bite fits your mood.
Beyond pizza, Secret Stash offers salads, appetizers, and a full bar that keeps guests refreshed and relaxed. The garlic bread knots, tossed in butter and Parmesan, are a must-try starter. Pair your meal with a local craft beer, a glass of wine, or one of their signature cocktails. Whether you’re seated at the bar, a cozy booth, or the spacious outdoor patio, the dining experience is consistently warm and welcoming.
Service at Secret Stash is friendly, casual, and genuine—another reason guests return time and time again. The staff exudes the same joyful energy that defines the restaurant. They’re quick to offer recommendations, share a laugh, and make you feel like part of the Crested Butte family. In a town built on adventure and community, Secret Stash fits right in as a place where everyone can unwind and share great food.
Secret Stash isn’t just the best pizza in Crested Butte—it’s one of the best in Colorado. It perfectly blends creativity, quality, and local spirit into every dish. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or you’re a longtime fan, dining here is a reminder that great food doesn’t have to be fancy—it just has to be made with passion. If you find yourself in Crested Butte, don’t keep this secret to yourself.
Comments