top of page
Search

Savor the 4th of July: Ten Great Apple Pies in Colorado Springs, plus one.

  • Writer: Keisha R.
    Keisha R.
  • Jun 28
  • 6 min read

Nothing captures the spirit of the Fourth of July quite like a slice of classic apple pie—and in Colorado Springs, the choices are as plentiful as the fireworks. Whether you love yours warm and cinnamon-spiced, stacked high with apples, or topped with a scoop of creamy vanilla ice cream, there’s a pie here to suit every craving. We’ve scouted the city’s bakeries and cafés to bring you 10 standout apple pies perfect for your Independence Day celebration. A few popular spots didn’t make the list—not because they lack quality, but because we focused solely on apple pies. No scones, strudels, tarts, cookies, or cheesecakes—just good old-fashioned apple pie. Here are 10 top picks, plus one honorable mention.


The list is ranked numerically and then alphabetically.

3.14 Pi Bar

5152 Centennial Blvd Colorado Springs, CO 80919

(719) 314-6172

Tucked away on Centennial Blvd, 3.14 Pi Bar in Colorado Springs is a charming neighborhood favorite known for its delicious lineup of sweet and savory pies—and their apple pie steals the show. Baked in a golden, flaky crust and filled with tender, cinnamon-spiced apples, this pie offers that nostalgic, comforting flavor that keeps guests coming back. Though their menu rotates with seasonal creations, the apple pie remains a crowd-pleaser thanks to its timeless, homey appeal. Whether you're enjoying a slice in their cozy dining space or taking a whole pie home to bake, it's clear that 3.14 Pi Bar takes pride in crafting fresh, irresistible pies from scratch.

Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery 

610 E Fillmore St, Colorado Springs, CO 80907

Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery in Colorado Springs crafts an apple pie that masterfully combines homestyle comfort with expert baking. Their Dutch apple and strawberry-rhubarb pies consistently earn glowing praise, often described as “absolutely fabulous” and long-time favorites by loyal customers. Encased in a perfectly golden, buttery crust with just the right crisp, the pie’s filling features tender apple slices layered with warm, balanced spices and a subtle sweetness that never overwhelms. It’s the kind of treat that evokes nostalgia with every bite—ideal for starting the day with something truly special.

Famous Dave's (at the Baker's Square)

5245 N. Academy Blvd., Suite 102, Colorado Springs, CO 80918

(719) 434-4771

Famous Dave’s Apple Pie is a hearty, homespun dessert that delivers classic American comfort with every bite. Made from sweet, crisp Michigan Northern Spy apples, this pie bursts with flavor thanks to a generous seasoning of bold Saigon cinnamon. Each slice is enveloped in a flaky, award-winning pastry crust that perfectly balances buttery richness with a golden, delicate crunch. It’s a warm, spiced treat that captures the essence of traditional baking and leaves a lasting impression.

Gold Star Bakery

1604 S Cascade Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80905

Tucked inside the historic Ivywild School building, Gold Star Bakery in Colorado Springs has become the go-to spot for the city’s best apple pie. Originally launched as a popular pie truck, it has grown into a full-fledged bakery with support from the local Blue Star Group. Each season, owner Heather Briggs and her team craft a Dutch apple pie that strikes the perfect harmony between tart-sweet apples and a golden, flaky crust. Locals can’t get enough—not just of the pie, but of the welcoming, family-owned atmosphere. Whether you take home a whole pie or enjoy a slice with a cocktail or coffee next door at the Principal’s Office, Gold Star’s apple pie captures the heart of the season and the spirit of the community.

Icing on the Cake

15 N Union Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80909

At Icing on the Cake in Colorado Springs, every dessert is a handcrafted work of art, made with care and creativity for weddings, birthdays, and life’s most memorable moments. Known for their stunning, custom-designed cakes, this beloved bakery also offers special-order apple pies that are just as impressive—flaky, golden crusts filled with sweet, spiced apples and a touch of homemade magic. Whether it’s a grand celebration or a quiet gathering, Icing on the Cake delivers sweetness in every bite, baking love into every detail.

Kneaders Bakery & Cafe

3430 Cinema Point, Colorado Springs, CO 80922

Kneaders Bakery & Cafe in Colorado Springs offers a truly outstanding apple cobbler pie that strikes a perfect balance between sweet and tart. They use crisp Granny Smith apples, their bright acidity shining through a rich cinnamon and brown sugar coating that creates a wonderful depth of flavor. The cobbler-style topping is golden and slightly craggy, offering just the right amount of buttery crunch to contrast the soft, juicy filling. Every bite feels warm and comforting—like autumn in a spoonful—making it one of the most memorable desserts in town.

Nature's Start Bread Company

3312 Austin Bluffs Pkwy Colorado Springs, Colorado 80918

Nature’s Start Bread Company in Colorado Springs crafts a fantastic apple pie that tastes like a slice of homemade heaven. Their version features perfectly tart Granny Smith apples layered generously with warm cinnamon and brown sugar, all tucked inside a buttery, golden crust that’s baked to flaky perfection. Each bite delivers a nostalgic blend of sweet and spiced comfort, with just the right amount of apple tang and tender texture. This pie isn’t just a dessert—it’s a small-batch masterpiece that celebrates simplicity, quality, and the heart of home baking.

Perkins American Food Co.

3295 E Platte Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80909

When you're in Colorado Springs, don't miss the Homestyle Apple Pie at Perkins Restaurant & Bakery on E. Platte Ave—it’s a true local favorite. Brimming with tender, cinnamon-kissed apples and wrapped in a golden, flaky crust topped with a sweet crumb or caramel drizzle, every bite tastes like it came straight from grandma’s oven. Guests love the rich, buttery crust and the perfect balance of flavors and textures. Whether enjoyed with friends or as a solo indulgence, it’s the kind of warm, nostalgic dessert that keeps folks coming back for more.

Sweet Elizabeth's Organics

1625 W Uintah St K, Colorado Springs, CO 80904

Sweet Elizabeth’s Organics in Colorado Springs crafts an apple pie that’s both heartwarming and impressively inclusive. Completely gluten-free, vegan, and free from the top nine allergens, it delivers all the nostalgic flavor of a classic pie without the usual ingredients—ideal for those with dietary restrictions or anyone who appreciates thoughtful baking. Guests frequently praise the bakery’s commitment to quality, noting that everything they offer is consistently delicious despite the absence of dairy, eggs, and other common allergens. Whether you're avoiding gluten or simply love a cleaner, kinder slice of pie, this one’s a standout.

Village Inn

535 Garden Of The Gods Rd. Colorado Springs, CO 80907

(719) 598-5331

The Village Inn in Colorado Springs serves up a truly memorable apple pie crafted with sweet, crisp Michigan Northern Spy apples—known for their perfect balance of tartness and sweetness. These premium apples are seasoned to perfection with aromatic Saigon cinnamon, delivering a warm, spiced flavor in every bite. The filling is tucked into a golden, flaky, award-winning pastry crust that adds the perfect buttery crunch. This classic dessert is a standout, capturing the essence of a comforting, home-baked treat while showcasing the skill and care Village Inn puts into every slice.

Honorable Mention: Whole Foods Bakery

7635 N Academy Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80920

We don’t often include grocery stores in our lists, as we typically highlight small, specialty bakeries and local vendors—but the apple pie at the Pikes Peak Whole Foods Market in Colorado Springs absolutely earns its place. This location’s bakery turns out a classic 9-inch pie (also available in handy half-pie portions) with a buttery, flaky crust and a generous filling of crisp apples seasoned just right—not overly sweet, but warmly spiced. Baked fresh daily by the in-house team, these pies are so popular that they often sell out by midday. Pro tip: call ahead and have a whole pie reserved. Whether you enjoy it warm from the oven or topped with a scoop of Colorado-made ice cream, this pie delivers comforting, crowd-pleasing flavor in every bite.

As the fireworks fade and the last grill marks cool, there’s no sweeter way to end your July 4th celebration than with a slice of all-American apple pie. Whether you're a fan of buttery crumble tops, perfectly spiced fillings, or flaky golden crusts, Colorado Springs offers a pie for every patriot’s palate. So grab a fork, gather your crew, and let one of these local favorites bring the perfect finish to your Independence Day feast.



 
 
 

Commenti

Our opinions are entirely our own, shaped by our experiences and insights, and we strive to provide honest and thoughtful perspectives. We welcome your feedback, whether it’s to share your thoughts, offer a different viewpoint, or start a meaningful conversation. Your input helps foster a dynamic exchange of ideas, and we appreciate the opportunity to engage with our audience.  Feel free to contact us.

bottom of page