High Mountain Pies - The Best Pizzas in Leadville, Colorado

Perched high in the Colorado Rockies at an elevation of more than 10,000 feet, High Mountain Pies has earned a reputation as one of Leadville’s most beloved dining destinations. For more than two decades, locals and visitors alike have made this charming pizza shop a must-visit stop, drawn by its unforgettable pizzas, welcoming atmosphere, and commitment to quality. Whether arriving after a mountain hike, a ski adventure, or a scenic drive through the Rockies, guests quickly discover why so many people consider this one of the finest pizza experiences in Colorado.

One of the first things customers rave about is the crust. Countless visitors describe it as the star of the show—crispy on the outside, soft and airy on the inside, with a texture that somehow manages to be both bread-like and almost cake-like at the same time. Every bite delivers the perfect balance of crunch and tenderness, creating a foundation that elevates every pizza on the menu. It is the kind of crust that leaves diners talking about it long after they leave town.

High Mountain Pies has built its reputation not only on traditional favorites but also on an impressive collection of creative specialty pizzas. The famous San Luis pizza consistently receives glowing praise for its combination of seasoned pork, green chile, avocado, cilantro, and cotija cheese. Customers frequently describe it as exceptional, unique, and unlike anything they have tasted elsewhere. Equally memorable is the Crocodile pizza, which has become a favorite among adventurous diners seeking bold and unexpected flavor combinations.

The menu offers much more than outstanding pizza. Guests often highlight the large, fresh salads and sandwiches that are generously portioned and bursting with flavor. The spinach salad, in particular, has earned praise for being large enough to satisfy multiple diners. Wings are another standout item, arriving crispy, meaty, and perfectly seasoned. Whether choosing BBQ wings, buffalo wings, or pairing them with one of the restaurant’s handcrafted pizzas, customers consistently describe the food as fresh, satisfying, and expertly prepared.

Another reason visitors return again and again is the remarkable attention to quality ingredients. Reviews frequently mention fresh dough, premium toppings, flavorful sauces, and pizzas made to order. From the hearty Carnivore to the crowd-pleasing Deluxe, every pie arrives hot, generously topped, and packed with flavor. Even a simple cheese pizza earns rave reviews for its excellent balance of sauce, cheese, and crust, proving that the kitchen excels at both classic and specialty offerings.

The atmosphere adds another layer of appeal. While indoor seating is intentionally cozy and limited, the outdoor patio and backyard dining area create a relaxed mountain-town experience that guests absolutely love. Families appreciate the spacious outdoor setting, while couples and groups enjoy gathering around heaters on cool Colorado evenings. The charming blue building has become a recognizable landmark in Leadville, contributing to the warm and inviting character that defines the dining experience.

High Mountain Pies is also known for its exceptional customer service. Reviews repeatedly mention friendly, attentive staff members who go above and beyond to make guests feel welcome. Team members such as Pablo and Kan are frequently praised for their professionalism, hospitality, and genuine enthusiasm. Visitors often comment that the service feels personal and sincere, creating an environment that feels less like a restaurant and more like a gathering place among friends.

Beyond the food and hospitality, the business embraces its community roots by offering special events such as its popular Backyard Performances, which feature live music on Thursday evenings. These gatherings bring together locals and visitors in a relaxed outdoor setting that perfectly captures the spirit of Leadville. Combined with a thoughtfully selected beer menu and a laid-back atmosphere, these events transform an ordinary meal into a memorable mountain experience.

For anyone visiting Leadville, this pizza destination consistently ranks among the highlights of the trip. Guests regularly describe it as one of the best pizzas they have enjoyed anywhere in the United States, praising its consistency, creativity, freshness, and welcoming environment. Whether enjoying a legendary San Luis pizza, savoring crispy wings after a day on the trails, or relaxing on the patio with family and friends, High Mountain Pies delivers an experience that keeps customers coming back year after year.

115 W 4th St, Leadville, CO 80461

(719) 486-5555

https://www.hmpies.com/