Eatery 66 North – Best New American Restaurant in Montrose, Colorado
Tucked into the heart of downtown Montrose, Colorado, Eatery 66 North is a welcoming destination where creative American cuisine, locally sourced ingredients, and a lively atmosphere come together beautifully. Located at 232 East Main Street, this family-owned restaurant represents the next chapter in the story of Eatery 66, a beloved Western Slope establishment that has been serving the community since 2015. Owners Katie and Spencer Graves have brought their passion for good food and genuine hospitality to Montrose, creating a gathering place that feels both refreshingly modern and comfortably familiar. Whether you're stopping in for lunch, settling down for dinner, or exploring the day's specials, Eatery 66 North offers plenty of reasons to make it a regular stop.
The restaurant's personality is immediately apparent upon entering. Housed in an older downtown building with high ceilings and a charming, narrow layout, the space features inviting decor, upbeat music, and a relaxed, contemporary vibe. Guests frequently praise the atmosphere, describing it as warm, welcoming, and thoughtfully designed. There's an easygoing energy here that makes it equally suitable for a casual lunch, a date night, or an evening out with friends. More than simply a place to eat, Eatery 66 North aims to be a community hub where locals and visitors can gather over satisfying meals, refreshing drinks, and good conversation.
Behind the restaurant's distinctive approach is a genuine commitment to culinary quality. Spencer Graves brings substantial professional experience to the kitchen, having trained at the Culinary Institute of Charleston and worked in respected restaurants in San Diego and Telluride, including acclaimed establishments such as Allred's and The New Sheridan Chop House. His experience informs a menu that balances familiar comfort food with thoughtful preparation and creative touches. The Graves family established their original Eatery 66 in Ridgway after beginning with a farm-to-table concept in a 1996 Airstream. That history continues to influence their cooking today, with locally sourced grass-fed beef, seasonal produce, and organic products helping shape a menu that celebrates the flavors of Colorado.
One of the standout dishes is the Steak Frites, which has earned particularly enthusiastic praise from diners. The steak is served with truffle Parmesan fries and a rich red wine demi-glace or jus that complements the beef beautifully. One visiting food enthusiast described it as the best steak they'd enjoyed in years, praising the tenderness, careful seasoning, and outstanding sauce. Another diner was impressed by the generous portion and the value, noting that a comparable meal could easily cost considerably more elsewhere. Although one reviewer mentioned that their steak arrived cooler than expected during a busy service, the overwhelmingly positive feedback makes this a compelling choice for anyone craving a satisfying steak dinner.
Burgers are another major attraction, offering a delicious take on an American classic. The Mushroom Swiss Burger, featuring the familiar combination of savory mushrooms and melted Swiss cheese, has received praise alongside other creative options, including the Guac and Hawaiian burgers. The menu also reaches well beyond traditional burgers and fries. Fish tacos have delighted visitors with their outstanding flavor, while pork chops, steak dishes, and rotating entrees provide variety for diners looking for something different. Guests seeking lighter fare will appreciate the restaurant's broader selection, which includes options beyond the usual comfort-food staples. The kitchen's emphasis on fresh ingredients and made-from-scratch preparation helps give even familiar dishes a distinctive character.
Daily specials are another reason to visit more than once. A chalkboard highlights additional creations that change with seasonal ingredients, culinary inspiration, and local availability. One memorable meal included Olathe Sweet Corn Soup, a regional favorite that celebrates Colorado's celebrated sweet corn, alongside the Shala Love with grilled shrimp and the Mushroom Swiss Burger. The shrimp earned special praise, and the entire meal left a strong impression. These changing offerings allow the kitchen to experiment, showcase ingredients at their best, and give returning guests something new to discover. For anyone who enjoys restaurants that balance dependable favorites with unexpected culinary surprises, the daily specials are well worth exploring.
The beverage program adds another appealing dimension to the experience. Eatery 66 North features a selection of Colorado craft beers on tap, giving beer lovers an opportunity to sample regional favorites alongside their meals. Professional bartenders also prepare handcrafted cocktails, including the Oaxaca cocktail, which one enthusiastic guest singled out as a highlight of the evening. The combination of thoughtful drinks, flavorful food, and lively music creates an atmosphere that encourages diners to linger a little longer. Although the supplied reviews offer fewer specific details about desserts, the restaurant's commitment to scratch-made cooking and creative menus makes it a destination worth exploring from the first course through the final sip.
Service at Eatery 66 North follows a slightly different model from a traditional full-service restaurant, and understanding the system helps make the visit more enjoyable. Guests select a table, review the menu, and place their orders at the counter, where the staff can accommodate individual preferences and customizations. Food is then brought directly to the table, while water is available for self-service. Although some visitors initially prefer conventional table service, reviewers generally find the process straightforward and appreciate the friendly, knowledgeable team. The restaurant also receives praise for its prompt communication and welcoming hospitality. Combined with reasonable prices for the quality and portion sizes, the approach helps make a thoughtfully prepared meal feel accessible rather than extravagant.
For visitors exploring downtown Montrose and locals looking for a dependable new favorite, Eatery 66 North delivers a compelling combination of creative American cooking, Colorado ingredients, craft beverages, and genuine family-owned hospitality. Its menu has enough variety to satisfy different tastes, while its daily specials reward those who return to see what's new. The restaurant also welcomes inquiries about private dining, corporate buyouts, weddings, birthdays, holiday gatherings, and other special events, further reinforcing its role in the community. With the Graves family's decade-long commitment to the Western Slope behind it, Eatery 66 North brings both experience and fresh energy to Montrose's dining scene. Come for the Steak Frites, explore the rotating specials, enjoy a handcrafted cocktail, and discover a restaurant built around a wonderfully simple philosophy: Be Good. Live Simple. Eat Well.
232 E Main St, Montrose, CO 81401
(970) 765-0455
Comments