Best Pizza in Creede, Colorado: Old Miners Inn

Tucked deep within the rugged San Juan Mountains lies the small, historic mining town of Creede, Colorado—an off-the-beaten-path gem that surprises visitors with its vibrant charm, stunning natural surroundings, and culinary treasures. Among those treasures, the Old Miners Inn stands out as the undisputed champion of pizza in town. With its rustic atmosphere, warm hospitality, and unforgettable pies, this locally-loved establishment has become a favorite stop for both tourists and longtime locals.

The Old Miners Inn is more than just a pizza joint—it's a slice of Creede’s soul. Housed in a historic building that reflects the mining roots of the area, the restaurant features wooden beams, vintage signs, and a cozy, lived-in feel that invites guests to linger. The staff is friendly and welcoming, offering up recommendations with pride and a sincere passion for their menu. From families with kids to hikers passing through, everyone finds a seat and a smile at Old Miners Inn.

When it comes to pizza, Old Miners Inn doesn’t cut corners. Each pie is handcrafted with house-made dough that’s perfectly chewy with just the right crisp at the crust. The sauce is rich, tangy, and made in-house—balanced enough to let the toppings shine while still delivering a bold flavor punch. Every ingredient is thoughtfully sourced, and it shows in every bite. The menu features a robust range of specialty pizzas. Their "Mountain Man" is a hearty favorite, piled high with pepperoni, sausage, ham, green peppers, and black olives. It’s a filling and satisfying option after a long day exploring the trails or fly-fishing nearby. The "Creede Veggie" is another standout—loaded with mushrooms, spinach, red onion, and fresh tomatoes, it manages to be both indulgent and refreshing.

For those with more adventurous tastes, the "Ghost Mine" pizza—featuring jalapeños, spicy sausage, and a drizzle of hot honey—delivers a fiery, sweet-savory experience that lingers long after the last slice. Custom pizzas are also a hit here, allowing guests to build their dream pie from a wide range of fresh toppings. Gluten-free crust is available, and the kitchen is accommodating to dietary needs. Though pizza is the star of the show, the rest of the menu deserves praise. The garlic knots are addictive, served hot with a generous side of marinara. Their house salads are fresh and generously portioned, and the wings—crisp, saucy, and flavorful—are worth an order on their own. If you’re lucky, you’ll also find seasonal desserts like warm apple crisp or brownies à la mode.

A small but thoughtful beer and wine list rounds out the experience. Many diners opt for a locally brewed craft beer to complement their meal, adding yet another layer of Colorado authenticity to the evening. In the summer, the small patio offers a charming place to enjoy your meal outdoors while soaking in the cool mountain air.

The Old Miners Inn is more than just the best place for pizza in Creede—it’s a cornerstone of the community. Its enduring reputation stems not only from delicious food but from the way it captures the heart of this mountain town. Visitors come for the pizza and leave with fond memories of a welcoming place that feels like home.

If your travels take you through southern Colorado, make the detour to Creede and pull up a chair at the Old Miners Inn. Whether you’re craving classic comfort food or looking to explore a creative, bold pizza experience, you’ll find it here—hot from the oven, made with care, and served with the kind of mountain-town hospitality that keeps people coming back year after year.

105 N Main St, Creede, CO 81130

(719) 658-1233

https://www.oldminersinn.com/