Springside Cheese Shop – A Haven for Cheese in Pueblo, Colorado
For the cheese lovers in Colorado, I have a goodie for you to try - nestled in the heart of downtown Pueblo, Springside Cheese Shop has become a destination for cheese lovers from across Colorado and beyond. More than just a specialty food store, it's a welcoming gathering place where handcrafted Wisconsin cheeses, gourmet sandwiches, charcuterie, and locally sourced specialties come together under one roof. Whether you're searching for the perfect cheese board, a memorable lunch, or a unique gift basket, Springside offers an experience that celebrates both tradition and hospitality.
The story behind Springside Cheese stretches back more than a century. Its roots trace to Wisconsin's dairy heritage of the late 1800s, when European cheesemaking traditions helped transform the region into what would become known as "America's Dairyland." Founded in 1908 in the rolling hills north of Green Bay, Springside Cheese built its reputation on handcrafted cheeses made from fresh local milk. Through changing ownership and decades of dedicated craftsmanship, including a new chapter under cheesemaker Wayne R. Hintz in 1973, the creamery has continued producing award-winning cheeses recognized by the American Cheese Society, U.S. and World Championships, and the International Cheese Awards.
Today, that proud Wisconsin tradition lives on in Pueblo, where visitors discover an incredible assortment of handcrafted cheeses ranging from rich aged cheddars and creamy Colby to Monterey Jack, Gruyère, smoked mozzarella, blue cheeses, fresh squeaky cheese curds, and an ever-changing lineup of specialty creations. Flavor combinations like Apple Cinnamon, Chicken Soup, Ghost Jack, Beer Cheddar, Horseradish Chive, Caramel Norwegian, and Pueblo Chile varieties showcase the creativity that has made Springside a favorite among adventurous food lovers.
One of the shop's greatest strengths is its knowledgeable and passionate staff. Guests consistently praise the team for taking time to answer questions, recommend pairings, explain flavor profiles, and even offer generous samples before making a purchase. Whether helping customers build custom gift baskets, suggesting alternatives to hard-to-find cheeses, or calling loyal customers when favorite varieties return to stock, the personalized service creates an experience that feels both genuine and memorable. It's the kind of customer care that keeps people happily returning year after year.
While cheese may be the star of the show, Springside's deli has quietly earned a devoted following of its own. Their handcrafted sandwiches receive rave reviews for generous portions, fresh ingredients, and exceptional flavor combinations. Favorites like the Pueblo Pastrami, Turkey Sandwich, Pastrami Crunch, and rotating weekly specials have become lunchtime destinations in their own right. Many visitors suggest ordering ahead during busy lunch hours, a testament to the popularity of these freshly prepared creations.
Beyond cheese and sandwiches, the shop offers everything needed to build an impressive charcuterie spread. Shelves are filled with artisan crackers, fruit preserves, jams, maple syrup, breads, meats, spreads, wines, and carefully selected gourmet accompaniments. Customers appreciate the opportunity to discover locally produced specialties alongside imported favorites, making every visit an opportunity to find something new for entertaining, gifting, or simply enjoying at home.
The atmosphere inside Springside Cheese Shop is every bit as inviting as its products. Visitors often describe the store as warm, modern, elegant, and surprisingly spacious while maintaining the charm of a neighborhood specialty shop. Walking through the front door feels, as one customer noted, like entering "a world where all that exists is cheese." Friendly conversations, complimentary tastings, and thoughtful recommendations create an environment where both seasoned cheese connoisseurs and first-time visitors feel completely at home.
What makes Springside especially unique is its commitment to supporting the local community while honoring its Wisconsin heritage. The shop proudly features Pueblo's famous green chile in several signature cheeses, collaborates with other small businesses throughout Southern Colorado, and has become a trusted supplier for restaurants, catered events, and specialty gatherings. Visitors often recommend pairing a visit with a stop at a nearby wine bar, creating an afternoon that celebrates the very best of Pueblo's growing culinary scene.
For anyone who appreciates exceptional craftsmanship, outstanding customer service, and unforgettable flavors, Springside Cheese Shop deserves a place on every Colorado food lover's itinerary. More than a century after its founding, Springside continues fulfilling its original mission: creating authentic handcrafted cheeses that bring people together. Whether you're enjoying an award-winning cheddar, sampling inventive specialty cheeses, or savoring one of Pueblo's favorite sandwiches, every visit is a reminder that great food is best experienced when shared with family, friends, and a community passionate about quality.
517 W 5th St #104, Pueblo, CO 81003
Comments