The Best Pizza Spots in Colorado Springs, Colorado!
- Debbie G.
- Apr 9
- 8 min read
While Colorado Springs is famous for its breathtaking mountain views and outdoor adventures, it also offers a vibrant pizza scene that meets every craving. As a city with a strong military presence, pizza is a beloved choice for many locals. Whether you're craving a classic New York-style slice, a hearty deep-dish, or a unique wood-fired creation, the Springs has something to tempt every pizza lover. From charming neighborhood pizzerias to lively downtown spots, we've explored the city to bring you the top 13 pizza places that are sure to satisfy your hunger.
Listing below is offered alphabetically, not in an order of ranking
Billy’s Old World Pizza
308 S 8th St Unit E, Colorado Springs, CO 80905
Billy's Old World Pizza in Colorado Springs is a cherished family-owned gem, offering a handcrafted alternative to the mass-produced meals of corporate chains. Even better, they are famous for authentic Chicago-Style pizza. Dedicated to quality and tradition, Billy’s prepares everything on-site from scratch, ensuring a fresh and flavorful dining experience. For a truly hearty experience, Billy’s legendary “Stuffed” pizza is a must-try. Built in a deep, two-inch pan, it starts with a double-layered bottom crust, packed with generous handfuls of cheese and your choice of toppings, then finished with a rich, handmade sauce. These massive specialty pies can weigh between four and eight pounds, transforming a simple meal into a memorable feast. Based on Chicago Heritage and traditions, Billy’s serves award winning Italian Food, prepared completely on site under the direction of a great lover of Italian food.
Black Forest Pies and Grinders
11470 Black Forest Rd, Colorado Springs, CO 80908
Black Forest Pies & Grinders in Colorado Springs is celebrated for its exceptional handmade pizzas, featuring flavorful crusts and sauces crafted from scratch. Customers consistently praise the authentic taste and quality of the pies, often highlighting the freshness and richness of the ingredients. The restaurant offers a cozy, hometown atmosphere that enhances the dining experience, making it a favored spot for both locals and visitors seeking top-notch pizza. Beyond pizzas, their menu includes a variety of grinders, calzones, and appetizers, all prepared with the same commitment to quality. The friendly staff and excellent customer service further contribute to the establishment's strong reputation in the community. Best of all, everything is made fresh; fresh-to-order. Black Forest Pies & Grinders has been family owned and operated since 2001 with strong ties to the local community, serving Colorado Springs, Black Forest and Monument, Colorado.
Louie’s pizza
Multiple locations in Colorado Springs
(Barnes Rd., N. Tejon, E. Filmore, Briargate and Tutt Blvd)
Louie’s Pizza first opened its doors in 1985 at the corner of Barnes and Oro Blanco, laying the foundation for what would become a beloved local institution. Through dedication, hard work, and the hands-on approach of its owners, the brand grew to establish five community-rooted locations. In recognition of its impact, Louie’s was named the Colorado Department of Education’s PTA Business of the Year in 1995. Over the years, it has earned multiple accolades, consistently ranking among the top three for "Best Tasting Pizzas" and "Best Delivery" in Colorado Springs, as voted by readers of the Gazette and the Colorado Springs Independent. Today, Louie’s Pizza continues its tradition of quality and service, offering old school Detroit-style pizza, calzones, specialty pies, and its signature garlic cheesy bread at five convenient locations across the city. Their remarkable growth throughout Colorado Springs is a testament to the love of their pizza.
Mountain Mike’s Pizza
123 Spectrum Lp Suite 130, Colorado Springs, CO 80921
Mountain Mike’s Pizza in Colorado Springs brings the iconic taste of this PIZZA LEGEND to the heart of Colorado, continuing a tradition that started over 45 years ago with a single pizzeria and a dream. Known for its signature crispy, curly pepperoni and specialty pizzas crafted with the freshest ingredients, Mountain Mike’s is a go-to destination for families, friends, and sports fans alike. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, catching the big game, or simply craving a delicious slice, this welcoming, family-friendly spot delivers "Pizza the Way it Oughta Be." With a commitment to quality and flavor, every visit to Mountain Mike’s in Colorado Springs promises an unforgettable dining experience and legendary memories.
Orsetto Wood Fire Pizza
8 E Bijou St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
(719) 728-4144
Orsetto Wood Fired Pizza, located at 8 E. Bijou Street in Colorado Springs, Colorado, is an artisan food truck renowned for its naturally leavened sourdough pizzas baked in a traditional wood-fired oven. Crafted with 100% organic wheat and leavened using local Colorado cultures, each 12-inch pizza embodies a commitment to mastery, tradition, simplicity, and digestibility. The menu features a variety of options, including the classic Margherita with mozzarella, parmesan, garlic oil, tomato sauce, and fresh basil; the Pepperoni with mozzarella, tomato sauce, and oregano; and the White Pie, topped with mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, roasted garlic, truffle oil, and oregano. For the latest information on their serving locations and times, patrons are encouraged to follow Orsetto's Facebook page and click here to see their parking/location schedule.
P74: The Downtown Paninos
604 N Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
P74: The Downtown Paninos in Colorado Springs is a hidden gem for pizza lovers, offering an exceptional selection of handcrafted pies with bold flavors and high-quality ingredients. Their pizzas boast a perfectly crisp yet chewy crust, generously layered with rich tomato sauce, premium cheeses, and an array of fresh toppings that cater to both classic and adventurous palates. Whether you opt for a simple margherita or a specialty creation loaded with gourmet ingredients, each bite delivers a satisfying balance of textures and tastes. The warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly service make it an ideal spot for a casual yet delicious dining experience in the heart of downtown Colorado Springs. Aside from their pizzas, they have gluten-free options and fantastic paninis.
Papa's Italian Restaurant North
13280 Touchstone Vw ste 150, Colorado Springs, CO 80921
Papa's Italian Restaurant in Colorado Springs is a hidden gem for pizza lovers, serving up fantastic, authentic Italian flavors with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Their hand-tossed, stone-baked pizzas boast the perfect balance of crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, and gooey, high-quality cheese, with toppings that range from classic pepperoni to gourmet creations. Each bite bursts with fresh ingredients and old-world craftsmanship, making it clear why locals and visitors alike rave about their New York-style pizza. Whether you're craving a simple order of garlic knots, pepperoni or fully loaded specialty pizza, Papa's delivers a slice of Italian perfection in the heart of Colorado Springs. If you're in Florence, Colorado, you can also enjoy their location in that area as well. A wonderful pizza spot when hunger comes knocking.
PizzAria
2727 N Cascade Ave #165, Colorado Springs, CO 80907
(719) 659-0658
PizzAria is a small, family-run business, named after their daughter Aria. A family-owned business demonstrating a family-style philosophy. What could be better? PizzAria in Colorado Springs is a must-visit for pizza lovers, offering outstanding pies made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their hand-tossed crust is the perfect mix of crispy and chewy, complemented by rich house-made sauces and generous toppings. Whether you choose their famous 'Meatza,' 'East Coaster' or classic pepperoni, every bite is bursting with flavor. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service enhance the flavor even further and if you order it to go, your home will smell great throughout the evening. Their remarkably efficient takeout system ensures you can enjoy their delicious pizza anywhere. For some of the best pizza in Colorado Springs, PizzAria is a great choice.
Pizzeria Rustica
2527 W Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80904
Pizzeria Rustica makes you feel as if you are in a generations-old neighborhood trattoria in Italy while you enjoy a rustic yet refined pizza in a historic 1889 building and patio that's located in Old Colorado City. Enjoy the adjoining art and jewelry gallery while you can focus on a simple, locavore-inspired menu with daily chef’s market specials. The staff combines slow food movement standards in their preparation with fast firing of your menu selection in a pecan wood-fired oven. Consider our recommendations: Regina Super Margherita, Pontecorvo Salsiccia or the Salumi. A phenomenal experience and worthy of a visit. Enjoy patio seating or choose a carryout option. Your won't regret it.
Roadrunner Pizza
3113 N Hancock Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80907
Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta, located at 3113 N Hancock Ave in Colorado Springs, is a family-owned establishment that has been serving the community for over 37 years. Known for its commitment to quality, the restaurant prepares fresh dough daily, crafts sauce from fresh-packed ground tomatoes, and grates a custom cheese blend in-house using 100% real mozzarella, smoked provolone, and cheddar cheeses. The menu features a variety of offerings, including numerous options of delicious, different pizza toppings, continual specials, specialty pizzas, and pasta dinners as well as wings, pastas, desserts and much more. A quick search online will show you that their customers continually praise the friendly service, fresh ingredients, and generous portions, with one reviewer noting, "The pizzas are made with care and the ingredients are so clean and fresh. They're generous with all their toppings as well which we appreciate." Roadrunner Pizza & Pasta offers several options for any pizza or pasta lover. Visit them online, give them a call and order one of their greatest sellers - "The All Meat Masterpiece," "The Crusty Cajun" or perhaps "The Island Delight." You won't be disappointed.
Slice 420
2501 W Colorado Ave #108, Colorado Springs, CO 80904 (multiple locations)
Slice 420 is a family-owned pizzeria in Colorado Springs, renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza and community-driven mission. Established by Christian and Stefany, who relocated from Florida to Colorado to access alternative medical treatments for their daughter Sofia, the restaurant not only serves generous slices topped with fresh ingredients but also raises awareness and supports families with special needs children. With two locations—one on the east side at 3725 Oro Blanco Dr and another in Old Colorado City at 2501 W Colorado Ave—Slice 420 offers a diverse menu featuring nearly 20 gourmet pizzas, including unique options like the "Mountain Man" and the "Sofia Pie." Their dedication to quality and community has earned them the top spot in the 2023 Best of the Springs awards.
Upstate Pizzeria
19 N Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Upstate Pizzeria, located at 19 N Tejon Street in Colorado Springs, CO, is a standout New York-style pizzeria celebrated for its thin, foldable crust and well-balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio. Nestled inside North Tejon—a lively food hall with multiple dining options and a full bar—the pizzeria offers a casual, welcoming atmosphere with plenty of seating, making it a great choice for lunch or dinner. While the pizza is seriously good and often hailed as some of the best of its kind in the area, the real star might just be the wings: crispy, flavorful, and totally addictive. The second-floor setting adds to the appeal, and the bar makes it an ideal spot to grab a drink with friends. Owner Richie is known for his hospitality, making guests feel right at home. For great food, a fun vibe, and a relaxed experience, Upstate Pizzeria is a must-visit.
Walter's303 Pizzeria & Publik House
2690 North Gate Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80921
Walter's303 Pizzeria & Publik House in Colorado Springs is renowned for its exceptional pizza, offering a variety of crust options, including deep-dish and cauliflower crusts, all generously topped with fresh ingredients. Patrons frequently praise the flavorful combinations and quality of the pizzas, noting that each bite is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to excellence. Beyond the delectable menu, the establishment boasts a warm and inviting atmosphere, complemented by a friendly and attentive staff that enhances the overall dining experience. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Walter's303 provides a memorable culinary destination for pizza enthusiasts. Walter's303 Pizzeria & Publik House operates in several locations - Colorado Springs, Denver and Littleton.
No matter what style of pizza you prefer, Colorado Springs has a spot that will hit the mark. Whether you're a local looking for a new favorite or a visitor eager to taste some of the city's best slices, these 13 pizzerias are sure to impress. With their high-quality ingredients, expert craftsmanship, and unique flavors, each of these pizza spots brings something special to the table. So, grab a friend, order your favorite toppings, and enjoy some of the best pizza Colorado Springs has to offer!
Comments