The Best Pies, Fillings & Baked Goods in Lyons, Colorado: the Colorado Cherry Company

Within the scenic foothills near Lyons, Colorado, the Colorado Cherry Company stands as one of the most beloved destinations for pies, fillings, and baked goods in the state. Positioned along the road to Estes Park and the Rocky Mountains, it offers more than just a quick stop—it delivers a full sensory experience rooted in tradition, comfort, and unmistakable Colorado flavor. For travelers and locals alike, it’s a place where the aroma of fresh-baked crust meets crisp mountain air.

The story begins in 1929, when a family matriarch perfected her cherry pie recipe—one that would become the cornerstone of a multi-generational business. Today, the Colorado Cherry Company remains a fourth-generation, family-owned operation, carrying forward a legacy built on consistency and craft.  What started as a simple roadside stand has grown into a regional institution, yet it has never lost sight of its roots: simple recipes done exceptionally well.

At the heart of the experience is the iconic cherry pie—arguably one of the best in Colorado. Made with tart Montmorency cherries and encased in an all-butter crust, it strikes a perfect balance between sweet and tangy.  Each bite delivers a bright, fruit-forward flavor that avoids the overly sugary profile found in lesser versions. It’s the kind of pie that doesn’t need embellishment, though a scoop of vanilla ice cream certainly doesn’t hurt.

While cherry may be the star, the menu extends far beyond a single flavor. Guests will find a rotating selection that includes apple, blueberry, pecan, pumpkin, French silk, and creative hybrids like cherry streusel or cherry cheesecake.  Seasonal offerings keep things fresh, ensuring there’s always something new to try. Each pie shares the same foundation: a rich, flaky crust that serves as the backbone of the entire menu.

One of the most appealing aspects of the Colorado Cherry Company is the ability to take the experience home. Their shelves are stocked with house-made cherry pie fillings, jams, jellies, and sauces—perfect for recreating that mountain bakery magic in your own kitchen.  Whether you’re baking from scratch or simply topping pancakes or cheesecake, these products capture the same vibrant fruit flavor found in their pies.

Though best known for sweets, the menu also includes a lineup of savory baked goods that deserve attention. Chicken and bison pot pies, for example, offer hearty, satisfying alternatives with the same signature crust.  These dishes reflect a broader philosophy: great baking isn’t limited to dessert—it’s about technique, texture, and flavor, whether sweet or savory.

The Lyons location, nestled in Pinewood Springs, offers a particularly memorable setting. Surrounded by natural beauty, it’s the kind of place where you can sit with a slice of pie and a cup of coffee while taking in views of Colorado’s rugged landscape.  It’s no surprise that this stop has become a tradition for road-trippers heading toward Rocky Mountain National Park.

What makes the Colorado Cherry Company special isn’t just the quality of its baked goods—it’s the sense of place. Everything feels intentional, from the rustic charm of the shop to the carefully preserved recipes. Even the expansion of the business has stayed true to its identity, with each location maintaining that same high-country authenticity.

In a world full of bakeries, the Colorado Cherry Company rises above by doing one thing exceptionally well: honoring tradition while delivering consistent excellence. Its pies are not trendy or overcomplicated—they are timeless. And in Lyons, Colorado, that simplicity becomes something extraordinary. Whether you’re after the perfect cherry pie, a jar of filling, or a comforting savory bake, this mountain gem delivers one of the finest bakery experiences in the state.

12311 N. ST. VRAIN RD, Lyons, CO 80540

(303) 823-2324

https://coloradocherrycompany.com/